"When the Devil Chose Me" Chapter 3 — The Mafia Dinner
Emily stared at the message on her phone for a long time.
"Lunch today."
Not *Would you like lunch?*
Not *Are you free?*
Just… lunch.
Sofia paced across the room like a nervous cat.
"You're not going," she said for the fifth time.
Emily rubbed her forehead.
"I didn't say I was."
"You're thinking about it."
Emily hesitated.
That was the problem.
She "was" thinking about it.
Alessandro Romano was dangerous.
Everyone in Florence apparently knew that.
But the memory of his voice… his calm confidence… the way he looked at her like he already understood her…
It lingered in her mind.
Sofia crossed her arms.
"You're not seriously considering dating a mafia boss."
"I'm not dating him," Emily said.
"You got a text that basically said *come eat with the mafia*."
Emily sighed.
"Technically it just said lunch."
Sofia groaned.
"You Americans are going to get yourselves killed."
Emily grabbed her phone again.
For a moment she considered ignoring the message.
But curiosity burned too strongly.
She typed:
Emily:
You didn't ask if I'm free.
The reply came instantly.
Alessandro:
You are.
Emily rolled her eyes.
Three dots texted.
Then another message.
12:30.
I will send a car.
Emily stared at the phone.
"You see?" Sofia said. "That's not a date. That's a kidnapping with appetizers."
Emily hesitated… then typed back:
Fine.
Sofia screamed into a pillow.
---
At exactly 12:25, a sleek black car stopped outside Emily's apartment building.
Sofia peeked through the curtain.
"Oh my God," she whispered.
"What?"
"There are two cars."
Emily frowned.
"Why two?"
Sofia looked horrified.
"Because mafia bosses travel with security!"
Emily grabbed her coat.
"Well… at least I won't get mugged today."
"Emily!"
"Relax," she said with a grin.
"I'm just having lunch."
---
The restaurant sat on a quiet street near **Piazza della Signoria**.
It looked small from the outside.
But inside, everything was elegant and private.
The host immediately led Emily past the main dining room.
"To the private terrace, Signorina."
Emily blinked.
"You know who I am?"
The man smiled politely.
"Of course."
That answer did not make her feel better.
When she stepped onto the terrace…
Alessandro Romano was already there.
He stood near the railing overlooking the city.
Black suit again.
Dark sunglasses.
Like a man who stepped out of a movie about powerful criminals.
He turned as she approached.
"Emily."
She sat across from him.
"You really do the dramatic entrance thing well."
"Habit."
She looked around.
The terrace was completely empty except for them.
"You reserved the entire place?"
"Yes."
"That seems unnecessary."
"I dislike interruptions."
Emily raised an eyebrow.
"You mean witnesses."
His mouth curved slightly.
"Something like that."
A waiter appeared with menus.
Alessandro didn't even look at his.
"Bring the usual."
The waiter nodded instantly.
Emily watched him walk away.
"You come here a lot."
"Frequently."
She leaned forward slightly.
"So."
"So?"
"Everyone in my apartment now thinks I had dinner with the Italian mafia."
"And?"
"Are they wrong?"
Alessandro took off his sunglasses.
His dark eyes met hers calmly.
"No."
Emily blinked.
He said it so casually.
No denial.
No hesitation.
Just… yes.
She sat back slowly.
"Well."
"That was honest."
"I prefer honesty."
"You're a crime boss."
"I run a family."
"That's a very polite way to describe organized crime."
Alessandro watched her carefully.
"You're not frightened."
Emily shrugged.
"Should I be?"
"Most people are."
"Well," she said lightly, "most people don't invite mafia bosses to lunch."
The corner of his mouth lifted again.
"You accepted my invitation."
"That's because I'm curious."
"About?"
"You."
Their food arrived then.
Fresh pasta.
Wine.
Bread that smelled incredible.
But Emily barely noticed.
Because Alessandro hadn't looked away from her once.
Finally she asked the question that had been sitting in her mind since yesterday.
"Why me?"
Alessandro tilted his head.
"You truly want to know?"
"Yes."
He leaned slightly closer.
"Because you walked away from a man who did not deserve you."
Emily felt her breath catch.
"That can't be the only reason."
"No."
"Then what is?"
His voice lowered.
"You look at the world like you expect more from it."
Emily blinked.
"That's… oddly specific."
"And rare."
She stared at him.
A strange warmth spread through her chest.
Alessandro picked up his wine glass.
"And because," he added quietly, "I like the way you challenge me."
Emily laughed softly.
"Most people probably don't challenge you."
"They do not."
"Well," she said with a playful smile, "I'm American."
---
ADVERTISEMENT
You May Also Like
-
CompletedChapter 15
The Sixth Year After I Escaped the Vandermeers
At eighteen, Elliot Vandermeer discovered that he was the wrong son in one of America's most powerful old-money families. The real heir had been found. The family trust was being rewritten. Six powerful men were discussing how to keep Elliot under control. So he disappeared before they could take away his name, freedom and future. For six years, Elliot lived as Nolan Gray, moving between cities and building a quiet life as a rare-book restorer. He believed he had escaped the Vandermeers—until all six men appeared at his wedding in Ireland. Dragged back to the storm-darkened Blacktide Estate, Elliot discovers that his escape was never as successful as he believed. Someone paid his medical bills. Someone erased his immigration violations. Someone protected him in Brussels. Someone watched his apartment from across the street. They always knew where he was. At the center of the trap is Leander Vandermeer, the true heir whose life Elliot supposedly stole. Leander doesn't want his inheritance returned. He wants the man who vanished before they ever had the chance to meet. As buried medical records, altered birth certificates and a decades-old kidnapping conspiracy surface, Elliot must decide which danger frightens him more: the family that refuses to release him, or the desire that keeps pulling him toward the man who finally opens the door. The way out is waiting. This time, staying must be Elliot's choice.Dark Secrets|Plot Twist|Yandere|Possessive Love|Sweet Romance|HE9.8k words5 4 -
CompletedChapter 11
ABSOLUTE SUBMISSION
Betrayed and sold out by his best friend, pop icon Kian was supposed to be just another disposable plaything for the elite. When he was delivered to Alistair Vance—the most ruthless, untouchable billionaire in the industry—everyone expected him to break. Instead, Kian pressed a jagged shard of glass straight to the magnate's throat. Alistair despised anything he couldn't control, until he became utterly obsessed with the rebel who dared bite back. What starts as a cold, dangerous contract explodes into a ruthless war of vengeance and absolute devotion. They'll burn the entire empire to the ground—and on the ashes, the king will bow.Mutual Pining|Plot Twist|Possessive Love|Redemption Arc12.8k words5 20 -
CompletedChapter 18
I Keep Waking Up in My Straight Roommate's Arms
Every third night, Noah drank the warm milk his straight roommate made for him. Every morning, he woke up with a new bruise. So one night, Noah poured the milk away and pretended to sleep. At 2:07 a.m., Adrian entered his bedroom. And what Noah discovered was far more dangerous than anything that could have been hidden in the milk.Healing Romance|Plot Twist|Yandere|Possessive Love|Sweet Romance|HE15.8k words5 737 -
CompletedChapter 12
The Vulture's Captive
"By day, he is the cold-blooded monster who rules the Chicago syndicate, and she is the fierce heiress who refuses to bow. By night, the masks shatter." Aurelia Vance was traded to the Bratva as a human lien—a pawn to settle her bankrupt family’s multi-million-dollar debt. Viktor Volkov, the ruthless Pakhan known as The Vulture, expected a terrified trophy wife to break in his gilded cage. He expected submission. Instead, he got a platinum-haired storm with violet eyes who looked at a loaded gun and dared him to pull the trigger. Trapped in a world of blood, mafia politics, and a marriage built on chains, Aurelia vows to burn his empire to the ground. But Viktor didn't spend years engineering her downfall just to let her go. He wants her broken, he wants her defiant, and above all, he wants her to love the monster who stole her life.Mutual Pining|Dark Secrets|Plot Twist|Possessive Love|Redemption Arc|Sweet Romance13.3k words5 19