"My Stepbrother Hated Me—Until I Stopped Wanting Him" Chapter 4
What He Wouldn't Deny
"Because I don't feel about you the way I should."
Nate said it quietly. I heard every word.
I stopped wiping my face.
He looked at the space between us, then back at me.
"I saw you with that man at the bar, and I wanted him to leave. When you leave a room, I notice how long it takes you to come back. I know how that sounds."
My breath caught.
"Then don't tell me I'm imagining it."
"You're not."
For three weeks, I'd built explanations that made his behavior hurt less. Guilt. Family duty. A temporary interest in becoming a better person.
Now he'd taken all of them away.
"How long?" I asked.
"I don't know when it started. I know I shouldn't have let you keep wondering."
I looked past him at the closed door.
Downstairs, Claire was wearing a ring.
"What are you going to do?"
He moved one step closer, then stopped himself.
"I need to think."
I almost laughed.
"You've had a party about it."
He flinched.
I hadn't meant to be cruel. For once, I didn't hurry to fix the effect of my words.
"I didn't understand what I was agreeing to," he said.
"Claire probably does."
His face changed then. Not anger. Recognition, ugly and overdue.
"You're right."
"I'm not asking you to leave her for me tonight. I'm asking you to stop making me feel like there's something here when you won't do anything about it."
"There is something here."
The certainty in his voice hurt worse than a rejection.
"Then take care of it," I said. "Don't keep handing it to me and acting surprised when I can't put it down."
For a long moment, neither of us spoke.
He lifted his hand, slowly enough that I could have stepped toward it.
I didn't.
He let it fall.
"All right," he said.
He looked as though he wanted to say more. Instead, he went downstairs.
I sat on the bed until the music ended.
At midnight, Ben answered on the first ring.
"Tell me where you are."
"My room."
"Do you need me?"
I stared at the door Nate had finally closed without my wishing he would stay.
"Can you just talk?"
So he talked about the guy who had spent twenty minutes explaining cryptocurrency to him beside the buffet. He complained about the tiny plates. He described the cab driver's spectacular hatred of cyclists.
Eventually, I laughed.
Then I cried hard enough that he stopped making jokes and stayed on the phone while I did it.
The next morning, I came downstairs early.
The house looked embarrassed. Half-empty glasses stood on windowsills. Flowers leaned in buckets beside the kitchen. Someone had abandoned a single expensive shoe beneath the piano.
I made toast.
Nate came in as I was putting the jam away.
"You don't have to leave because I'm here," he said.
ADVERTISEMENT
"I'm leaving because I have a seminar."
"On Saturday?"
"Research workshop."
He knew. I'd told him four days earlier. It seemed to occur to him a second after I answered.
"Right."
I picked up my bag.
"Will you be back for dinner?"
"I haven't decided."
He stood beside the coffee machine with his hands empty.
"Could we talk later?"
"Have you thought?"
His eyes held mine.
"Not enough."
"Then not yet."
I left before my courage noticed what I'd done.
On the bus, I kept expecting relief. Instead I felt sick and proud and lonely in alternating bursts.
At the workshop, a graduate student named Tessa asked whether I could help prepare materials for a summer project. Normally, I would have asked which evenings it involved before saying yes.
This time, I said I'd check my class schedule.
My own schedule.
It felt like learning to write with the other hand.
Nate sent a message at noon.
Have you eaten?
I stared at it for a while.
Then I wrote, Yes. Thank you.
No joke. No question that would keep the conversation alive.
He didn't reply.
That evening, I ate with Ben in his apartment above a bakery. The windows rattled when the buses passed. One kitchen drawer required encouragement and a knife to open.
"Very glamorous," I said.
"You can visit a rich person if you need better drawer access."
He handed me a plate of pasta.
I told him what I'd said to Nate.
Ben didn't ask for every word. He listened, then pointed his fork at me.
"If you need somewhere to stay, the sofa turns into a bed. Allegedly. I've never trusted it enough to try."
"Thank you."
"You'd have to tolerate my personality."
"I'm already doing that for free."
He smiled. It made the room feel less small.
I went home at ten.
Nate was in the living room, a book open on his lap.
He wasn't reading it.
"Good evening," I said.
"Good evening."
I made it to the stairs before he spoke again.
"Did you have a good day?"
I looked back. Under the lamp, he seemed almost absurdly handsome, which felt like an unnecessary complication.
"Some of it."
He nodded once.
"I'm glad."
He didn't ask where I'd been.
I went upstairs and shut my door.
For the next four days, we practiced politeness.
I stopped asking whether he wanted coffee. I stopped staying downstairs after my work was finished. If Mom asked me to take something to his room, I said I was busy, and sometimes I actually was.
On Tuesday, Martha put his mug beside mine by habit.
I moved it to the other end of the counter.
Nate saw.
He said nothing. That was becoming more difficult to bear than his sharpness.
On Wednesday night, I found the blue blanket outside my door, folded, with a note on top.
Martha says the laundry service can fix the shedding. I asked them to try.
I sat on the floor and read it twice.
Then I put the blanket on my bed and left the note in the drawer.
The next morning, I thanked him.
His face softened so suddenly that I almost reached for the rest of the conversation.
Instead, I picked up my bag.
"Elliot," he said.
I stopped.
"I miss talking to you."
I believed him.
That was what made the answer hard.
"I miss it too."
He waited.
"But I can't be the place you come to feel better about a decision you won't make."
For once, I let him be the person left standing in the hall.
ADVERTISEMENT
You May Also Like
-
CompletedChapter 18
So I'm Your Puppy Now?
I only wanted to survive my first week at a new university. So when three guys cornered me, I panicked and told them the scariest guy on campus was my boyfriend. Ryan Blackwood. Basketball captain. Campus bad boy. The guy nobody dared mess with. And apparently… my hopelessly lovesick puppy. I told everyone he begged for my kisses, couldn't sleep without my goodnight texts, and was completely obsessed with me. It worked perfectly. Until Ryan found out. One afternoon, he cornered me in an empty alley, leaned close, and smiled. **“So I'm your puppy now, sweetheart?”** I thought I was dead. Instead, he decided to play along...BL20.2k words5 0 -
CompletedChapter 12
Straight Until the Lights Went Out
The night Whitmore University loses power, Noah Bennett loses hours of code and his first kiss. He knows three things about the guy who kissed him: he was taller than Noah, his heart was racing, and he was terrible at it. Unfortunately, all four of Noah’s roommates are taller than him. So Noah texts each of them the same thing: **Your kissing sucks.** One asks if he’s really that bad. One thinks Noah has the wrong number. And Evan Hart, the quiet computer science genius in the bunk across from his, sends a single question mark. Evan is the first person Noah rules out. He’s also the only one who offers to help him find out who did it. Then Noah stumbles across an anonymous campus account where someone’s been writing about his roommate for six weeks. The roommate borrows his charger, apologizes every time, and sleeps with one arm hanging off the bed. Noah knows exactly who those posts are about. What he can’t explain is why he keeps looking across the room at Evan.BL|Sweet Romance|HE16.1k words5 22 -
CompletedChapter 16
Scoring on My Football Captain Stepbrother
On his first day at Westbrook University, transfer student Alex Dunne catches the star quarterback trying to charm his way out of a failing grade. Liam Hatton threatens to make his life hell if he tells anyone. That evening, Alex finds Liam by the pool at his mother’s new husband’s house. The quarterback who told him to keep his mouth shut is his new stepbrother. Now they sleep down the hall from each other, and Alex has to earn his place as a wide receiver on Liam’s team. Liam thinks Alex has been handed everything. Alex thinks Liam could use a reminder that being captain doesn’t make him untouchable. Then Liam catches Alex getting ready for a date with another teammate, and for one breathless second, neither of them is thinking about football. When a photo from a team party puts Liam’s championship spot on the line, Alex can protect his own place on the roster by staying quiet. He’s already done that for Liam once. This time, staying quiet might cost him the one person he wants beside him when the stadium lights come on.BL|Sweet Romance|Fake Relationship|HE20.7k words5 94 -
CompletedChapter 12
Sold to the Rival I Secretly Loved
Jesse Malo was undefeated until someone offered him fifteen thousand dollars to stay down. With his six-year-old daughter waiting for heart surgery, Jesse takes the money and throws the fight. Then an furious bettor storms into the locker room, demanding to know why Jesse cost him half a million dollars. It’s Grant Whitmore. The boy Jesse fell for in high school. The man who still believes Jesse stole the girl he wanted. Seven years later, Grant can afford to buy as much of Jesse’s time as he wants. He starts with a private sparring session, a two-thousand-dollar check, and one rule: Jesse can’t hit back. For every round he lasts, Grant will add another zero. Jesse knows exactly how many rounds he needs to last. But standing across the ring from Grant again, he has to wonder how much longer he can keep the promise that separated them seven years ago.BL|Dark Secrets|Fake Relationship|Second Chance16.4k words5 26 -
CompletedChapter 14
Seducing My Sister’s Husband Behind Her Back
For ten years, William Blake has brought white flowers to Leon Ryder’s races. It’s easy enough to explain. Leon is a champion, and William is married to his sister. Then Leon walks past the cameras after another win and tells William he doesn’t care why he came. He just wants him there. Hours later, William is patching up Leon’s knuckles when Leon asks why he hasn’t divorced Fiona. William has made a career out of helping people leave unhappy marriages. He has no answer for his own. And when Leon tells him Fiona is seeing someone else, William has even less to say about the fact that he’s looking at Leon’s mouth. Fiona’s affair gives William a reason to leave. Falling for her brother means admitting what he wants after he does.BL|Age Gap|Dark Secrets|Fake Relationship|HE18.9k words5 151 -
CompletedChapter 13
Claimed by the Dragon Prince
“You killed my father.” The dragon prince smiled. “I went to a great deal of trouble to be captured by you.” Commander Lucian Winters has the man he blames for his father’s murder in chains. He only needs to reach into Kaelen’s mind and find the truth. Then the chains snap. Kaelen knows Lucian’s scent. He remembers the winter they met. And he remembers a promise he made to a boy in the snow fifteen years ago, on a night someone erased from Lucian’s memory. When Lucian’s own house brands him a traitor and orders his execution, he has to run with the dragon he swore to kill. Kaelen knows what happened on the night Lucian’s father died. The longer they spend together, the harder it gets for Lucian to decide what scares him more: that Kaelen might be telling the truth, or that he wants the dragon to stay even after he’s heard it. Then Kaelen leaves a golden mark on his throat, and Lucian discovers just how much a dragon means when he says he’ll never let go.BL|Dark Secrets|Dragons|Second Chance16.3k words5 12 -
CompletedChapter 18
The Mafia King's New Toy
My family lost everything overnight. Our fortune. Our reputation. Our freedom. And somehow, I ended up owing **$500 million to Dante Moretti—the most feared Mafia King in New York.** I thought he would kill me. Instead, he handed me a contract. **One year as his personal maid.** A black-and-white maid uniform. Ridiculous rules. Humiliating chores. And a dangerously handsome boss who seemed to enjoy making me lose my temper. “Put it on, pretty boy.” I hated him. His arrogance. His wicked smile. The way he always knew exactly how to make me blush. But somewhere between our endless arguments, his shameless teasing, and the nights I spent too close to him, something began to change. The man who owned my family's debt started getting jealous whenever someone else touched me. The Mafia King who never bowed to anyone began breaking his own rules for me. And when I discovered the truth behind my family's downfall, I realized the man I was falling for might also be the one who could destroy me. **I was supposed to be his maid for one year.** **So why was the Mafia King acting like he wanted to keep me forever?**BL|Maid/Nanny|Mafia|Age Gap|Dark Secrets|Plot Twist|Contract Relationship|Possessive Love|Sweet Romance|HE18.8k words5 136