"We Were Never Supposed to Fall in Love" Chapter 1
The second hand ticked on, each beat unnaturally shrill in the empty, dimly lit living room.
I sat on the edge of the sofa, scrolling aimlessly across my phone screen, though my gaze kept drifting toward the closed front door. The night outside had grown deep. The city's neon sliced through the gaps in the blinds, cutting cold, orderly patches of light across the wooden floor. There was a suffocating heaviness in the air, like the low pressure that settles in before a storm, pressing down until I could hardly breathe.
My name is Peter. In this absurd living arrangement, I had always felt I was playing a supremely awkward part. Schroeder and I — both of us were, thoroughly and completely, bottoms.
In our circle, that was supposed to mean we were insulated from each other. We should have been good sisters: swapping cosmetics, grumbling about the wrong men we'd met, even splitting a bottle of red wine on weekend nights to curse out whichever scumbag had wronged us that week. And in fact, that was exactly how we had first defined each other. We lived together, split the steep rent, and maintained a roommate relationship that was safe, comfortable, and absolutely incapable of striking a spark.
At least, until today, I had believed that with unshakable certainty.
Click.
The sound of a metal key sliding into the lock was magnified a hundredfold in the silent night. My heart skipped a beat for no reason at all. The door swung open, and the pale sensor light from the hallway flooded in, casting a tall, straight silhouette onto the entryway rug.
It was Schroeder.
He had just come from an important dinner party, still wearing that custom-made, deep navy three-piece suit. Its tailoring was exquisite, clinging perfectly to his broad shoulders and narrow waist. In the dim light, the fabric carried an expensive, cold sheen. His hair was slicked back with gel, not a strand out of place, baring that sharply defined, handsome, almost blade-like face.
But tonight, he felt different.
He didn't, as he usually did, kick off his leather shoes the moment he stepped inside and complain that his tie was choking him half to death. He simply stood quietly in the entryway and closed the door behind him. The click of the lock falling into place was like an invisible bolt sealing the entire space shut.
"You're back," I said flatly, trying to break the uneasy silence. My voice came out faintly tremulous in the quiet room.
Schroeder didn't answer immediately. He set his long legs in motion, his leather shoes landing dull, rhythmic thuds against the wooden floor as he came toward me step by step. As he drew close, a blend of expensive woody cologne, a faint trace of tobacco, and something dangerous — something that belonged to the chill of the night — wrapped around me all at once.
ADVERTISEMENT
He stopped in front of me and looked down from above. In those deep eyes there was none of the usual careless languor; in its place burned a fiercely restrained dark fire, the kind that seemed capable of swallowing a person whole. His jawline was drawn tight, and a nearly tangible tension radiated off him.
He was in a terrible mood tonight. I could feel it.
"You… what's wrong? Did the dinner go badly?" I instinctively shrank deeper into the sofa and tilted my head up to look at him.
Schroeder remained silent. Slowly, he raised a hand, his long fingers finding the tie at his own throat. It was a dark grey silk tie, knotted in a perfect Windsor, fitted flush against the collar of his white shirt.
His movements were unhurried, carrying a chilling sort of elegance. His finely boned fingers tugged gently at the knot, loosening it bit by bit. The silk whispered against itself with an almost inaudible shhh — and in this terrifyingly quiet room, it somehow carried a strange erotic charge.
"Stand up," he finally said. His voice was low and rough, with a tone of command that left no room for argument.
I froze. This wasn't how he usually spoke to me. The usual Schroeder, though sharp-tongued now and then, always carried the easy looseness of one of your own kind.
"Schroeder, what the hell has gotten into you—"
"I said, stand up." He cut me off. His tone didn't sharpen, but the pressure in his eyes made my breath catch.
Instinct outran reason. I actually obeyed him, rising to my feet on legs that had gone oddly weak. I had on nothing but an oversized lounge T-shirt and a pair of cotton trousers, and before the impeccably dressed, fully armored Schroeder, I suddenly felt like prey about to be offered up — utterly defenseless, with nowhere to run.
Before I could react, Schroeder suddenly closed the distance between us by a step. His tall frame blotted out the light in an instant, swallowing me whole beneath his shadow. He seized my wrist, his grip shockingly strong.
"That hurts! What are you doing—"
I struggled on instinct, but he wrenched my arm back, effortlessly forcing both my hands behind me. Then a cool, slick sensation wound around my wrists.
It was that dark grey silk tie of his.
"Schroeder! Have you lost your mind? Let me go!" I cried out in panic, thrashing with everything I had. But his movements were fast, ruthless, precise — that tie, a symbol of elite polish and restraint, had become the sturdiest of shackles. He looped it twice around my wrists and drew it into a hard knot.
Silk was soft to the touch, but once pulled taut it was astonishingly strong. I could feel the fabric biting into my skin until the blood in my veins seemed to run slow.
ADVERTISEMENT
"Quiet," he murmured against my ear, his warm breath spilling over its shell and sending an uncontrollable shudder through me. "You're being far too loud, Peter."
There was no anger in his voice — only a cold, almost perverse composure. It terrified me as I had never been terrified before. Was this still the roommate who debated with me over which brand of lube felt best? The man standing before me, dressed in formalwear with eyes as savage as a wolf's, was nothing less than a brute in a suit.
He gave me a shove. I staggered a few steps and tumbled awkwardly back onto the sofa. With my hands bound behind me I couldn't keep my balance; I could only kneel at the sofa's edge in a mortifying forward hunch, my chest heaving.
Schroeder stood over me, drinking in my disarray from above. Slowly he unbuttoned his suit jacket, shrugged it off, and flung it carelessly onto the armchair nearby. Then his hand drifted to his waist.
A crisp metallic clink rang out.
The sound of a belt buckle coming loose.
My pupils shrank to pinpoints. Fear coiled up my spine like a cold serpent. Helpless, I watched him draw out that belt of expensive black calfskin. With a swish, it carved a vicious arc through the air, letting loose a whipping sound that froze the blood.
"Wh-what are you going to do?" My voice shook past all recognition. We were both bottoms — how could this drama of domination and violence possibly be playing out between us?
Schroeder folded the belt in half and closed his fist around it. His white shirt had gone faintly creased from the struggle, the cuffs pushed up to his forearms, baring the hard, clean lines of muscle beneath. He looked at me, and one corner of his mouth lifted into an arc of such cruelty it was almost beautiful.
"Helping you see reality."
The words had barely landed when his arm swung up.
Crack!
A sharp, ringing slap of leather detonated through the living room.
ADVERTISEMENT
You May Also Like
-
CompletedChapter 11
After My Ex Lost His Memory, I Found Someone New
I spent three years chasing Grant Whitmore. Three days after he finally agreed to date me, he woke up in a hospital bed and asked who I was. I knew he was lying. So I smiled, introduced myself as his assistant, and handed in my resignation. My recovery plan was simple: return to the bar I half owned, wear something devastating, and stop organizing my life around a man who couldn’t admit he wanted me. Then Noah Ellis needed a place to stay. The younger dancer was sweet, handsome, and very good at making breakfast. Giving him the guest room seemed harmless. Until a dance lesson ended with his hands on my hips and a question I desperately wanted to answer. Now my ex wants another chance, my houseguest wants to kiss me, and I’m beginning to suspect the shy one has been pursuing me all along.BL|Dark Secrets|Second Chance10.9k words5 0 -
CompletedChapter 10
My Rival Makes a Terrible Fake Husband
Jamie Bennett had a perfectly good plan: embarrass himself at the engagement party, let his childhood rival reject him, and escape their families’ matchmaking. Adrian Hayes agreed. Then he stood up, applauded, and announced he’d fallen in love. Now Jamie is married to the most infuriating man he knows, with a two-year agreement and one very clear warning: don’t expect love. Fine. Jamie can handle that. What he can’t explain is why his supposedly indifferent husband remembers his favorite dessert, finds increasingly flimsy reasons to linger beside him, and arrives at a party he claimed he was too busy to attend. Then a handsome young musician takes an interest in Jamie. And Adrian’s performance as a husband who doesn’t care begins falling spectacularly apart.BL|Billionaire|Love After Marriage|Sweet Romance|HE9.2k words5 0 -
CompletedChapter 10
The Little Girl Who Called a Billionaire’s Bluff
Ethan Cole offers a struggling caterer’s daughter a million dollars to make him walk. His wealthy guests laugh—until ten-year-old Lily tells him she saw him standing the night before. Ethan has spent eighteen months hiding his rehabilitation, grieving his brother, and shutting people out. Lily refuses to be intimidated by his money or his temper. Then she recognizes the silver medal beneath his collar. Her late father left something for Ethan. What begins as a cruel joke becomes a promise—and an unexpected bond between people learning how to live with the ones they’ve lost.Billionaire|Human Nature|Dark Secrets|Second Chance9.8k words5 0 -
CompletedChapter 11
She Told the Mafia Boss to Smile—Then He Recognized Her Camera
Clara Bennett has spent eleven months cleaning Lorenzo Duca’s mansion and keeping her three-year-old daughter out of his way. Then Mia points an old camera at the feared Mafia boss and orders him to smile. Clara expects anger. Instead, Lorenzo goes pale. The camera belonged to his mother. It was recovered from the crash that killed her fifteen years ago. When a photograph slips from its worn leather case, Clara recognizes someone who should have no connection to the Duca family: her own mother, holding Clara as a baby. Mia only wanted a picture. Now Clara needs answers—and Lorenzo must open the doors he has kept closed for years.Billionaire|Dark Secrets|Second Chance|HE10.4k words5 0 -
CompletedChapter 11
I Hid My Name—Then Got Pregnant by the Mafia Heir
For four years, Emma Hayes has survived by hiding the name she was born with—and the truth about her parents’ deaths. One night with Alessandro Vitali was supposed to be the exception. No past. No explanations. No morning after. Six weeks later, she’s pregnant. Then the mafia heir appears at her door, discovers the baby, and produces a photograph someone took of her without her knowledge. On the back are four words: Ask her real name. Alessandro offers protection, but trusting him means stepping into the world she’s spent years avoiding. And as their attraction becomes something neither can walk away from, Emma discovers a connection between their families that could destroy them both. She’s carrying his child. But can she trust him with the truth?Billionaire|Dark Secrets|Glow-Up|Love After Marriage11.6k words5 2